DV Journal

In the wake of the 2024 election, there is a dispute over how big the Amish vote for Trump was in Pennsylvania. The Wall Street Journal leans toward an increase of Amish voters in 2024, and The Philadelphia Inquirer dismisses that theory.

The battle is important for two reasons. Producing more Amish voters was part of the GOP’s strategy in Pennsylvania and is a major reason why conservative activist and voter turnout guru Scott Presler is being so widely touted.

Presler, a frequent guest on my show, would often call me from an outdoor farmers’ market with a lot of Amish, gun shows with hunters, and truck stops with, you guessed it, truckers. He mined these locations for unregistered Trump voters. This approach worked incredibly well, and maybe more importantly Presler is hiring more staff for New Jersey’s 2025 governor’s race and the three Pennsylvania  Supreme Court seats up next year.

Presler told the New York Post, “I didn’t invent the wheel. I just took the Democrats’ tools and used them to elect Republicans.”

He was in many ways the Trump ground game in Pennsylvania, targeting counties like Bucks and Luzerne and flipping them red. He made the weekly release of voter registration numbers an event like a lottery drawing. He has already started working on Sussex County in New Jersey using the same tactics.

Linda Kerns flanked by Joe DeFelice (left), her attorney overseeing Philadelphia, and Tom Petruczuk, the RNC election entegrity director for Pennsylvania. The trio had just learned they called Pennsylvania for Trump.

He recently tweeted to his over two million followers on X that the town council of Edison, N.J.  has banned the American flag and other props from its meetings, and suggested it would be a good idea to show up with lots of flags and a voter registration table. That is the type of concentrated activism that gets publicity and results.

In fact, Presler said on my radio show that he has chosen Wildwood to be a premier spot for his operations in spring and summer of 2025 due to its reputation as a vacation spot for people from Pennsylvania and New Jersey. A generous Wildwood boardwalk vendor has ready given him a spot to set up his registration table.

The other person who moved the needle for Trump in Pennsylvania was attorney Linda Kerns. Kerns was the Trump campaign’s 2024 Pennsylvania Election Integrity Counsel. She was so efficient and relentless in fighting in court to make sure election laws were followed that Talk Radio 1210 listeners accepted voting by mail-in ballot and thus greatly increased Trump’s numbers.  \And she has not closed up shop but is already strategizing to insure election integrity in the 2025 Pennsylvania elections. Her bio on Twitter says, “Election integrity equals freedom.”

Presley and Kerns are really the tip of the spear driving and directing the forces of change ready to wash over America. Yet, any number of Democratic Party leaders have not gotten the message and are still talking down to voters.

On Dec. 2, the Democratic members of the House Ways and Means Committee’s X account posted ,”Record air travel, holiday shopping busting records, stock market at all-time highs. The economy is ‘the worst ever’ some Pollyannas whine. And here we were thinking y’all couldn’t afford eggs!” Does that sound like people who get how the Biden administration policies created huge and predictable inflation that harmed Americans? Or does it sound like the elite attitude that the Democratic Party can’t hide from American voters.

The governor’s race in New Jersey and the Supreme Court races in Pennsylvania will be the next battlegrounds. I wouldn’t bet against Presler, Kerns, and energized voters.

How does conservative firebrand and Republican gubernatorial nominee Doug Mastriano play in the Delaware Valley? Is his passionate America First nationalism a bridge too far for Delaware Valley residents?

There’s no dispute Matriano underperformed in the Philadelphia suburbs. While he won the state with nearly 44 percent of the vote — and 20 points ahead of his nearest competitor, former Congressman Lou Barletta — he got less than half that in Delaware County.

In Bucks County, Mastriano won 39 percent, in Chester 32 percent, in Montgomery County 36 percent and 33 percent in Philadelphia. Part of the reason is related to the fact that his competitors Bill McSwain and David White had strong connections to the area.

However, it’s also likely related to Mastriano’s far-right candidacy, including advocating a total ban on abortion without exceptions, campaigning on explicitly religious themes, and his wholehearted embrace of President Donald Trump’s unsubstantiated claims he won the 2020 presidential election. Not exactly the profile of Republicanism in the home of Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick, one of the most bipartisan members of Congress.

However, though they might not have voted for him in the primary, most Republicans the Delaware Valley Journal spoke to now say they support Mastriano in his race against Democrat Attorney General Josh Shapiro.

“I like him,” said Philadelphia resident Elliott Tessler. “But I know he has certain foibles that might be deleterious to a possible election. I’m not put off by anybody being called a Trumper or Trump supporter. That doesn’t turn me off. And his big claim to fame is championing the challenge to the (2020) election. I’m not an election conspiracy guy, but I don’t think the Supreme Court decided correctly…How do you know what the numbers were until you did an investigation?”

Austin Hepburn, a Radnor resident active in politics, is enthusiastic about Mastriano’s chances to win in the fall.

“I go fly fishing upstate, toward the Poconos, out west toward Altoona,” said Hepburn. “And in my drives, I’m just overwhelmed by the number of Mastriano signs I see. I go upstate to hunt in the fall, and I see an awful lot of Trump signs. The Trump signs are still up. So the people upstate like Mastriano. And frankly, I can’t say I’ve ever seen an advertisement for him. I’ve never seen him speak…I was a little surprised that someone came and put Mastriano signs up at our polling place. Some of the people that came in told me they were voting for Mastriano. I was taken aback by that. I was a Dave White guy.”

Democrats, who already have a $6 million ad campaign targeting Mastriano on abortion, “are going to attack anybody,” said Hepburn. Some people asked him, “‘Don’t you think if Mastriano wins, they are going to drag him through the dirt, they are going to rip him apart with criticism?’

“And I said, ‘You know what, if the Republicans were to nominate Jesus Christ for governor, (Democrats) would still drag him through the mud and crucify him.’ So I don’t think that Mastriano is going to get any different treatment than any other Republican…The Democrats will go after anybody. It doesn’t matter. They’ll find some fault, whoever the candidate is, and try to wreck him.”

And as for Mastriano’s participation in the January 6th “Stop the Steal” protests that spun off into the Capitol Hill riot, Hepburn said he doesn’t believe that will be a problem.

“A lot of people have doubts about the election, and they want answers. It will be positive to get the base out. The Republicans can’t alienate their base like they do so often. It helps to have the base.”

But John Featherman, a Philadelphia Republican, believes the opposite is true.

“I am not a fan of him or his ideology,” Featherman said of Mastriano. “He will lose to Shapiro by 15 to 20 points. Many Republicans like me support a woman’s right to choose, as well as LGBT rights. We also don’t support ‘the big lie’ that Trump won the presidential election. Many of us will cross party lines and vote for Shapiro.”

Featherman, who ran for the U.S. Senate twice and for Philadelphia mayor in 2011 added, “Mastriano will also hurt the eventual Republican nominee from the U.S. Senate race–unless that person distances himself from Mastriano.”

Yet other area Republicans are ready to back the former Army colonel and state senator.

Myron Goldman, chair of the Cheltenham Township GOP, said, “I am glad to support a candidate who openly and enthusiastically supports conservative positions.”

Warminster resident Maryann Brown supports Mastriano, noting former Trump backs him. She said she hopes if Mastriano is elected, “gas prices go down and also food prices.”

“I have a part-time job in Center City Philly, and there are lots of homeless people. I work also in Levittown and northeast Philly, and the homeless are just asking for money, too,” said Brown.

Rich Booker, a former Radnor commissioner agrees that Trump’s endorsement helped Mastriano and that his attendance at the Jan. 6 rally before the Capitol riot had no affect on the primary voters.

“Trump’s endorsements seem to be based on his evaluation of who is most likely to win in the general election – after all, that is the most important consideration for Republicans,” said Booker.  “Trump’s support of Mr. Mastriano confirms that in his view, he has the best statewide ‘name recognition.’ and is the best primary candidate to reform election procedures to eliminate COVID-related and other changes that are susceptible to fraud or abuse within the Commonwealth  The Pennsylvania Republican primary electorate obviously agrees.”

And the Republican National Committee (RNC) says it is willing to do its part, too — though without mentioning Mastriano by name.

“The Republican National Committee has been on the ground in Pennsylvania since 2016, making a monumental investment this cycle as we work to elect Republicans up-and-down the ballot,” said Rachel Lee, a spokeswoman for the RNC. “Josh Shapiro would be a disaster for Pennsylvania families and workers, who will soundly reject him at the ballot box this November.”

Follow us on social media:Twitter: @DV_Journal or Facebook.com/DelawareValleyJournal