Montco Republican Wants Constitutional Ban on Illegals Getting PA Drivers Licenses

Republican state Rep. Donna Scheuren held a press conference Monday to announce a bill for a constitutional amendment to prevent illegal immigrants from obtaining driver’s licenses.
“The American people sent a message to the legislators in the country last November,” said Scheuren (R-Gilbertsville). “They wanted to see more direct action on the issue of illegal immigration.”
To that end, she’s proposing an amendment to Pennsylvania’s constitution, which is harder to change than passing legislation.
“There are many tragedies happening all around us that make this legislation necessary,” she said. “Over the past year, there have been multiple incidents of illegal immigrant drivers causing accidents killing or severely injuring American citizens.”
“These accidents are causing unnecessary heartbreak to American families,” said Scheuren. “These policies (to allow illegal immigrants to get licenses) not only undermine immigration law, but incentivize illegal immigration and strain state resources by requiring additional work to verify identity.
“We cannot afford to burden our constituents by allowing those who already committed a crime by coming into our country illegally, with the opportunity to freely drive on the public roadways of Pennsylvania,” Scheuren said.
Her proposed amendment to the constitution says, “The Commonwealth may not issue a driver’s license, operator’s license, operating privilege or other similar license, permit or authorization for operation of a motor vehicle to an individual who has not established lawful presence in the United States.”
Rep. Jill Cooper (R-Westmoreland), a cosponsor, said it is “vital” to place that into the state constitution. She cited an incident from Delaware County.
“The statistics from the last four years are not just numbers,” she said. “They represent lives affected and families shattered by a situation that we can no longer ignore. Consider this: In the United States, thousands of illegal aliens have been arrested for DUI: 1,629 in 2021; 1,614 in 2022; 2,493 in 2023; and a staggering 2,844 in 2024.”
Scheuren and Cooper cited tragic accidents called by illegal immigrants from around the country.
“In our own Pennsylvania, in Delaware County, Elifeo Agustin received his third DUI five years after crashing and injuring another driver,” said Cooper.
“So, from 2021 to 2024, a total of 8,580 illegal aliens were arrested for DUI,” said Cooper. “These statistics are not merely figures,” said Cooper. “They are a call to action.”
Republican Caucus Chair Rep. Martina White (R-Philadelphia) offered her support as well.
“According to U.S. Customs and Border Protection, three illegal aliens were arrested for murder in 2017,” said White. “Three in 2018 and two in 2019. However, in the four years of the Biden administration, the numbers for arrests of illegal immigrants surged to 60 in 2021, 62 in 2022, 29 in 2023, and 29 again in 2024.”
“By prohibiting the issuance of driver’s licenses to illegal immigrants, we can take a crucial step in preventing crimes on our roadways and enhancing public safety,” said White.
White noted more than a dozen states have laws that allow illegal immigrants to obtain driver’s licenses, including neighboring New York and New Jersey. “That undermines federal immigration enforcement,” she said.
“Recognizing the significance of this issue, U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi announced in February that the Department of Justice is suing New York for issuing driver’s licenses to illegal immigrants and obstructing immigration enforcement by restricting access to vehicle records…It is imperative that Pennsylvania stand on the side of law and order,” said White.
Some Democrats are not on board.
Joe Hohenstein (D-Philadelphia), who co-chairs the Welcoming Pennsylvania Caucus, told DVJournal, “Instead of instilling fear in Pennsylvania’s working-class immigrant communities, we should work together to improve road safety and ensure ALL drivers are properly trained and insured. We urge our colleagues on the other side of the aisle to work with us.”
He joined Democratic Reps. Johanny Cepeda-Freytiz (D-Berks) and Danilo Burgos (D-Philadelphia) in a joint statement opposing the amendment.
“As the May 7, 2025, REAL ID deadline approaches, we encourage all eligible permanent residents to take the necessary steps to secure their identification and ensure continued access to travel and essential services. We remain dedicated to advocating for policies that support immigrant communities and simplify processes for lawful residents across our commonwealth.”